Guides

Embroidery puckering: why it happens and how to stop it

By Sara Nelson · · 7 minute read

Embroidery puckers when the stitches pull the fabric tighter than the fabric can hold. The usual causes are a garment that was stretched in the hoop or a stabilizer too weak for the design, so check those two first.

The rest of the list is thread tension, a design that is too dense for the fabric, a worn needle, and fabric that shrinks after it is stitched. This page goes through them in the order I check them.

What puckering is

AllStitch's puckering article defines it as gathering or bunching of the fabric near the stitches. You see ripples around the edge of a fill, or a satin letter with the fabric drawn in on both sides.

Embroidery Library ran a side-by-side test that explains why it happens. Every stitch adds weight and tension to the fabric. That pull draws the fabric inward. A design with 35,000 stitches pulls a lot harder than a name on a left chest.

So puckering is the fabric losing a tug of war. Every fix below either makes the fabric stronger or makes the design pull less.

1. Check the hooping first

Madeira USA's page on avoiding fabric puckering says puckering is typically caused by fabric hooped improperly. Its fix is to re-hoop without making the fabric too tight.

The mistake most of us make is stretching the garment to get it drum tight. AllStitch's article explains what that does. A stretched garment gets frozen in its stretched shape while you stitch. When it comes out of the hoop the fabric relaxes back to its normal size. The stitching does not. That difference is the pucker.

Loose is wrong too. Kimberbell's list of five reasons embroidery puckers says the fabric should be taut but not overly tight. It names fabric left loose or stretched unevenly as a cause too. In Embroidery Library's test, fabric that was not hooped tightly enough was one of the three reasons a design puckered.

Here is how I hoop a knit now. I smooth the garment flat in the hoop without pulling it. My own note on a thin performance polo says it in four words: do not crank the hoop. An overtightened knit rebounds when it comes out and puckers around the stitching. On thin knits I use a magnetic hoop. It grips without the hoop burn a screw hoop can press into thin polyester.

Two more hooping habits help. Madeira USA and AllStitch both say to use the smallest hoop the design fits in. My guide to hard-to-hoop items covers beanies and baby clothes, where stretching in the hoop is the whole problem.

2. Then check what is under it

AllStitch's article calls inadequate stabilization the most common reason for puckering. The more the fabric stretches and the bigger and denser the design, the more stabilizer the job needs.

Embroidery Library's test shows what the wrong backing does. The same dense design puckered on quilter's cotton with tearaway. The tearaway began to fall apart during the stitching. The same design came out flat on medium-weight denim with medium cutaway and spray adhesive.

Which stabilizer to use is its own topic. These guides cover it:

More backing is not always the answer. The people in the stabilizer threads I read for those guides answer puckering complaints with density, underlay, and hooping far more often than with extra backing.

3. Check the thread tension

Madeira's best practice page on avoiding puckering calls thread tension the most important factor on delicate fabric. It says the lower the tension, the better.

The test is the back of the design. Madeira says it should show about one third bobbin thread and two thirds top thread. If you have a tension gauge, Madeira's page says to set the bobbin at 25 grams of force first and then set the top thread.

AllStitch's article warns that overly tight top and bobbin tension creates too much pull. It says to make only slight adjustments at a time. Embroidery Library calls a too-tight bobbin a less common cause and says to loosen the bobbin tension slightly if you suspect it.

Stitch a test on scrap after every tension change. Kimberbell's list says the same. Change one thing, stitch, look at the back.

4. Look at the design itself

Some designs pucker on some fabrics no matter how well they are hooped. Kimberbell's list says to lighten the design in your software or resize it if it is too dense. AllStitch's article says lighter and stretchier fabric needs lower density.

Madeira's page says to test the design first and then have the digitizer adjust the density, the fill and underlay stitches, plus the stitch direction. It also says to stitch from the inside of the design out to the edges.

Underlay is the layer of stitches that goes down first, under the stitching you see. AllStitch says the correct use of underlay can help stabilize the fabric. Madeira's page says to keep underlay to a minimum on delicate fabric. Both are true for their fabric, which is why the digitizer needs to know what the design is going on.

AllStitch also says designs made with an auto-digitizer can stitch poorly no matter what else you do. My guide on whether to learn digitizing or outsource it covers what good digitizing decides for each fabric.

When I order a file for a thin performance polo, I tell the digitizer the fabric on the order. A file built for a heavy sweatshirt is too dense for a light knit.

5. Check the needle and the thread

Madeira USA says a damaged needle can cause fabric pulls. Madeira's best practice page says to use the smallest needle that suits the thread, and lists a 60/8 or 65/9 for fine fabrics. Its page also suggests 60 or 75 weight thread for delicate or stretchy fabric.

My guide to needle sizes covers when a worn needle needs changing and why knits get a ballpoint. My guide to 40 weight vs 60 weight thread covers when the finer thread is worth it.

When a piece comes off the machine flat and puckers later

A piece that stitched flat can still pucker later. Embroidery Library's test pieces got worse after washing. Kimberbell's list says washing and ironing fabric beforehand can reduce shrinkage and puckering later.

The cause is shrinkage. A garment that has never been washed can shrink on its first trip through the dryer. The embroidery does not shrink with it, so the fabric gathers up around the stitching.

I had a waffle robe come in for a monogram. Waffle knit shrinks on its first wash, so I asked the customer to wash and dry it once before dropping it off. That customer had already washed it several times, so the monogram stayed flat. When a customer brings the garment, the wash goes in the drop-off instructions. My guide to embroidering customer-supplied garments has the full wording.

Polyester performance shirts are the one case nobody has solved. My no-show mesh guide covers shirts that stitch flat and still pucker after a wash, plus what has been tried.

Can you fix a pucker after it is stitched?

None of the five troubleshooting pages I read for this guide offered a fix for a finished piece. All five are about stopping it before the stitching starts.

So the fix for a puckered piece is stitching it again on a new garment. My guide on remakes and who pays covers how to handle that conversation. On a new blank, the remake is your cost.

That is the reason to stitch a test first. When a fabric is new to me, I run the file once on something close to it before the real garment goes in the hoop. An old workout shirt from a drawer works fine for a thin knit.

Write down what worked

Once a piece stitches flat, keep a record of the hooping, the backing and the speed that got it there. The next order for that design should start from them.

In Broidry, each design's own page has a notes box with fill-in lines for Stabilizer, Machine speed, Hooping, and Needle. Fill them in the day the piece stitches clean. My guide to thread color records covers what else goes in that record.

The short version

Puckering is the stitches pulling the fabric in. Check the hooping first: smooth and firm, never stretched, in the smallest hoop that fits. Then check the stabilizer, then the thread tension, then the design's density, then the needle. Ask for unwashed garments to be washed and dried once before you stitch them. Test new fabric on a scrap. Write down the setup that came out flat.

Run your whole shop from one place.

Broidry tracks every order, quote, and payment in one place. Broidry is free until your first sale, with no credit card to start.